How rotten that Floris didn't bother to label the samples! Or maybe some accident happened. How's a willing customer to know what to buy when he/she is sold on a great sample?
It sounds to me like you have JF right, but I'm not sure about No.2. It is a smooth, creamy sandalwood that doesn't call bergamot, pepper, or patchouli to my mind when I smell it. I regret I don't know the Floris line better to help more. Santal is a pale-chardonnay color though, you've got that right.
Good luck, Michael. Sorry I can't help further.