This is kind of an obvious answer, but you should really check out the rest of the modern men's Creed lineup. Original Santal is a great, strong cherry, while Original Vetiver has a nice candied neroli on top that smells like green orange candy (if that makes sense).
If you're looking for less expensive alternatives, lots of people think Sean John's I Am King smells like Millessime Imperial. For a real cheapie, Stetson All American has a Creed vibe to it as well.
For niche, if you haven't checked out Bond No 9 yet, you really should. They're very good at masculine scents that incorporate fruit. And speaking of Aventus, my favorite pineapple scent is L'Artisan Parfumeur Ananas Fizz.