I would pick Blue Label (Givenchy) out of that batch, because for one it's a great woody/aquatic scent and for two none of the other scents stand out much. You should definately reassess these scents though, because some of your impressions don't make much sense. For instance, Blue Label is actually pretty strong and lasts a really long time. I found the top notes to be annoying, but the drydown was very pleasant and surprisingly persistant. Often it takes a few wearings to know the true longevity of a scent. Trust me, Blue Label lasts.