Sorry can't provide a direct comparison, but I really liked the smell of eclat aparge. Definitely did seem citrusy at first and floral to powdery on the drydown, a good scent for hot or cold weather. I liked it that much that I bought a bottle for a good friend of mine and she raves about it, saying she wears it all the time and gets heaps of compliments. I actually found it for her at a direct factory outlet in the city, but have seen tester bottles and bottles on sale at chemists and other perfume stores in the city (Melbourne).
Hope that helps?!