Let's see, no niche, nothing classic, nothing too strong, something for a modern, sporty guy, but nothing too ozonic.
How about fresh fougeres like CK Eternity, Davidoff Good Life, Miracle Homme l'Aquatonic, (Platinum Egoiste, Paco Rabanne XS - are these fougeres?) I think these are quite versatile. If earthy-smoky is okay, try Terre d'Hermes or one of the Kouros variants. Not the original one though, that would snuff out what you are wearing. If creamy tonka is okay, try Burberry Brit. You are heading into winter right now, so I would normally recommend other scents, but winter scents tend to be strong.