I think its not bad either. I think people hate it because it not crazy unique or daring. I don't know why people even hate the bottle. I thought the bottle was nice and classy atleast as much as dior Homme.
It probaly a rather expensive bottle to make.If I weighed the bottle and atleast in my collection it would be the heaviest bottle. Beating out even 200 mL bottles when it itself is only a 100mL bottle.
People are probaly angry at YSL for making an generally unoffensive safe scent which makes them appear to sell out.