I samples Nautica Voyage...not bad but in the back of my mind I thought theres that end note or aftersmell tinge to it that irked me just a bit.
I even tried Perry Ellis 18, came out either in 2006 0r 2007? Now both Nautica Voyage and Perry Ellis are the safest clean smells you can get which some of us all love, but I do believe after thinking about it that you can just go right to POLO SPORT instead of getting either Voyages and perry Ellis...imho.
Nautica really is perfect for boating and the beach (lol lol Kramers beach cologne-Seinfeld) but I just think POLO SPORT is perfect in that atmosphere.
Perry ellis 18 you might like, I tried it and it smelled morose to me, hard to explain? It smelled like a clean soapy smell yet it has notes that are morose, not a fresh happy feel like POLO SPORT or Channel's Allure Sport.
I would go with nautica Voyage if you are going to choose between that and Island Voyage.
....however if you have time try those I mentioned you might like them better?