I usually just get an unscented or fragrance neutral aftershave balm (e.g, Nivea for Men Extrasensitive, Rexona for Men etc),
pour a bit of it into a plastic container top (like off a deordant can),
put three squirts of EDT into it,
mix with my finger,
then apply to face.
Your matching aftershave has been created. This technique works well for most scents, though it does mute a few a bit too much.