Erolfa maybe, if you want to stay in the aquatic department. Or SMW? Are you looking for a replacement that's still a Creed?
I know you'll get a lot of responses saying that you should appreciate MI purely on its merits and wear it if you like it...forget everyone else. But Unforgivable pisses me off too. I know it's illogical, and I know that there are differences between Unforgivable and MI, and I know that MI is by far the better scent overall. But COME ON! One of the many attractions of wearing a high end niche scent is to stand out from a crowd and not have everything *think* they know what you're wearing and take it for granted. Everyone having Unforgivable doesn't defeat the purpose of wearing MI, and if I had a full bottle I'm sure I'd still wear it, but it sure makes me a lot more hesitant to spend $100+ for a bottle.