It's certainly an opinion divider!
From what I can gather, it's the topnotes that put many people off. When I tried it, to run with the cliche, I found it very medicinal, and almost smelling what I'd imagine an old man's pyjamas to smell like! This blanketed the drydown, which is a shame, because as I understand it the drydown is quite similar to M7 Fresh, a fragrance which I wear non-stop.
Try it out and see what you think