Since you like the Creeds, I say Royal English Leather.
And if that doesn't move you, try Knize Ten... very classic and old school.
And if you want to share a leather with your wife, try Chanel Cuir de Russie.
And if you want an adventurous leather, try Tabac Blond.
And if you want a leather for the weekend, with a bit of sweetness, try SL Cuir Mauresque.