Code of Conduct
Results 1 to 9 of 9
  1. #1

    Default New Fragrant (possibly to find a signature one)

    Hi,

    I am new to this forum and I would like some advice.
    First of all let's start with my taste...or my lack of a signature smell right now.

    I own:
    Minotaure
    I love this one, warm, rich and deep. Very sweet, but not in a sharp way, nicely smooth.

    Chrome by Azzaro
    Fresh and unassuming, not too sweet. Nothing spectacular, but good for the office.
    Don't spray too much or otherwise it smells synthetic.

    Higher by Dior
    Nice smell, but a rather weak smell, because it doen't leave my skin.
    I chose this one at the time, because every other scents I smelled at the shop were too sweet.
    I don't like sweet that much, Minotaure is the only exception so far.

    Lancome Miracle L'aquatonic.
    Very very nice. I had a sample of Mugler's Cologne which I loved, but this one is even better, less sweet and less citrussy, more woodsy and it stays longer.
    Bought a 125ml bottle for only 25 bucks blind, I am thinking of buying another one before this edt is discontinued.

    Boss No.1
    A really awful smell, in interaction with other scents (perfume worn by other people) a urine smell comes on top. Brrrr.


    Fragrants I have owned:
    Cacharel pour L'Homme
    Very nice fougere, expressive, sharp at ones, but never overpowering, just a tad too sweet.

    Dior's Eau de Savage,
    Nice, but a bit one dimensional, too similar in smell and similar in its poor longetivity to an ordinary eau de cologne - which I like as well, but at least doesn't cost that much.

    Daniel Hechter's Caractere
    Nice one, woodsy, but a private affair too, the smell stays too close to the skin.

    Boss Elements
    Same story as with Caractere.
    I obviously like the darker, less sweet scents a lot, but I would like to find one that is a bit stronger and more outgoing.


    Fragrants I tried (from samples):
    Calvin Kleins CKIN2U.
    The dry down could be described as sugar made into a scent, so horribly sweet and non-substantial!

    DKNY for men.
    I wrote a favorable review for this fragrant (waiting to be approved), but wearing it for another 2 days I am beginning to doubt if this is the one for me.
    There's something very cold and unpersonal about this scent, high-tech if you like.
    Something I associate with an empty, symetrical design room, an interior which isn't put together piece by piece over the years, but at once.
    Less is less in this case.

    Dior's Fahrenheit.
    Beautiful smell, but way too heavy, that's why I was so lucky to find Minotaur at the time.

    Armani's attitude.
    Nice dry-down, but too similar to Minotaur, though not as warm, round and deep.
    Still it is even sweeter than Minotaure.
    Yes there are other differences between both scents: Attitude's opening for instance is all candy and spice in contrast with Minotaur's more citrussy one
    The different notes in Minotaurs "bouquet" are much richer, much more expressive.
    But to make an long story short: the middle and especially the dry-down is more important, while wearing a scent it is the overall character that counts and I find Attitude's character too similar to Minotaur's

    So there you have it.
    I don't like sweet.
    I want something more outspoken than the darker Caracter and Boss Elements I owned.
    I want a different smell than the ones I like and own.
    Preferably one I can wear anytime.
    Maybe a hybrid between a gourmand and a cologne?

    Could Guerlain's Vetiver be something I like? I don't want to smell like an old fart...I'm 35 by the way.
    Terre d'Hermes? Not too sweet?
    What about the classic Chanel Egoiste?

    Yes I'm aware of the appreciation for Creed on this forum and I really am curious about Bois du Portugal and Green Irish Tweed, but these fragrants are difficult to find over here and are pretty expensive.
    I rather buy 2 or 3 new edts than one Creed at the moment (but don't let that stop you from pointing me to the Creed direction

    I really would appreciate some help and opnions.
    Thanks.

    By the way, I can buy the following fragrants really cheap, but only through the internet this cheap, so I cannot try them first:

    Boss Bottled
    Boss Baldessarani
    Bvulgari pour Homme
    Cerruti 1881 Amber (read prommising reviews)
    Cerruti Si (My intuition tells me this one's too sweet. Is it?)
    Escada sentiment
    Mugler's B*Men (seems to be similar to the latest Armani Attitude, if so I'm not that interested)
    Nina Ricci Memoire d'homme (aftershave only)
    Versace Jeans (cute botte)
    Verace the Dreamer

    Any opnions on them?
    Thanks

  2. #2
    Basenotes Institution
    mikeperez23's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Location
    Miami, FL
    Posts
    26,711

    Default Re: New Fragrant (possibly to find a signature one)

    I think you will like Terre D'Hermes - in my opinion, it is not too sweet (remember you asked for a gourmand/cologne hybrid) but there is a citrusy sweetness that is quite nice. In addition, be prepared, because it has a mineral/rock smell that definitely is an acquired taste.

    If you don't like Terre D'Hermes I would try (from your list):

    BMen by Mugler
    Baldessarini by Boss

    Or (not on your list):

    Marc Jacobs for Men by Marc Jacobs (you have to like figs, to like this one)
    Rush by Gucci (really neat incense scent but not too smoky, cool packaging too!)

    I would avoid:

    Vetiver by Guerlain (I like this, but many others have described it as 'old' and it can give off that vibe)
    Versace Jeans (I really can't stand this - to me its mind numbingly boring)

    Good luck!

  3. #3

    Default Re: New Fragrant (possibly to find a signature one)

    Thanks! I appreciate this.

    Terre 'dHermes is on my shortlist...it actualy was already
    The only Gucci's I can get over here are Envy, Pour Homme and Nobile, no Rush unfortunately.
    Having read some reviews about Gucci Rush it appears to somewhat similar to Gucci Pour Homme.

    Marc Jacobs for Men by Marc Jacobs (you have to like figs, to like this one)
    I like figs, but am not so keen on cocos, because I already use a hair gel based on coconut oil...don't wanna smell like a Bounty.

    Vetiver by Guerlain (I like this, but many others have described it as 'old' and it can give off that vibe)
    Yes I was afraid of that...still I feel really tempted to buy one, is it the bottle I'm attracted to?
    If you can dose it carefully the strong scent may not be a problem...oh well there are many others to choose.

    Versace Jeans (I really can't stand this - to me its mind numbingly boring)
    I never gave this frag any attention and apparantly not without a reason
    Last edited by nout; 9th May 2007 at 07:31 PM.

  4. #4

    Default Re: New Fragrant (possibly to find a signature one)

    Welcome aboard. I see that we are around the same age. Unless you are wearing something extremely well known (i.e. Old Spice in the US might do it, and I could see how Vetiver might do it in Europe) I wouldn't worry too much about appearing aged.

    I was thinking you might like Egoiste since you like Minotaure before I got to the part of your post mentioning Egoiste. Personally I find Egoiste to be a little sweet, but not overly so. It has a lot of depth and wears different on me every time.

    Baldessarini is definitely sweet, so I would watch out. Very classy, but short duration.

    You might like Habit Rouge EDC; I'm getting Habit Rouge Legere which has the neroli notes making it more like a cologne from what I understand. I'll post about this one once I get it. I prefer Habit Rouge EDC to EDT due to its versatility.

    I see that you don't care for Eau Sauvage. You might try YSL Pour Homme if you want something with more obvious depth. Definitely citrusy but it has a dose of manliness which I think Eau Sauvage lacks. (Eau Sauvage has a bit of floral notes, i.e. jasmine which YSL PH lacks. YSL amps up the herbs.) I adore both the original YSL PH and the Haute Concentrate version, which has even more herbal notes than the original.

    B*Men has a lot of woods in it; this isn't even close to Armani Attitude IMHO. Attitude is more spicy. I don't think Attitude is bad but I wouldn't expect it to make a splash on Basenotes.

    Escada Sentiment reminds me of Escape for Men for some reason, although I haven't tried it in a while, I think you'll find to to be too sweet.

    BTW, if you like green notes, give Gucci Nobile a try if you can get it cheaply (in the US it is outrageously priced due to its being discontinued). The Miracle L'Aquatonic top notes are very grassy (for better or worse), while the top notes in Nobile are slightly citric, herbal and pine, while it dries down to an amber note. Nobile is another versatile fragrance.
    K
    MisterK / Vicomte de K / K
    Ephemeral Top 5: YSL PH HC, Worth PH, Equipage, Monsieur Rochas HC, Acqua di Gio

  5. #5

    Default Re: New Fragrant (possibly to find a signature one)

    Thanks MisterK.

    I think little by little I'm getting a better picture of what I like/will like.

    Gucci Nobile sells for €60, which would be something like $70 in the US for a 125ml (4.2 FL.OZ) bottle Eau de Toilette. I would say it is pretty much the same money you'll spend for a more recent quality fragrant.
    Not exactly cheap, but I checked some prices on the internet, a 4.2 FLOZ botte in the US will cost you a whopping $245!!
    So is this fragrant really that special?

    I'll definitely check B*Men and YSL Pour Homme as well.

    Thanks again
    Last edited by nout; 10th May 2007 at 05:30 PM.

  6. #6

    Default Re: New Fragrant (possibly to find a signature one)

    Guerlain Vetiver works great for me, and I'm 33. I'm with you on being a bit 'Meh' on Eau Sauvage, and it sounds like we have generally similar tastes overall. I'll throw in a second for Habit Rouge... I think the middle is outstanding, though it can occasionally get a little too 'Shalimar-ish' with the vanilla base.

    Agree about TdH being a bit of an acquired taste. Sometimes I liked it, sometimes it grated on me -- Probably not one I'd buy, though wouldn't mind having a decant around.

    I -really- didn't care for The Dreamer, found it cloying with a 'thick' sort of sweet that my nose just couldn't get around to liking. Could be it just ran amok with my chemistry.

  7. #7

    Default Re: New Fragrant (possibly to find a signature one)

    You might find Nobile a bit too "classic," though it is unquestionably a very fine scent.
    Avoid Guerlain's Vetiver and try L'Occitane's instead - no sweetness, earthy, dark, yet relxing and and a tad spicy, no sweets and not in any way "old-fashioned. I can also highly recommend Adolfo Dominguez Vetiver hombre for summer.

    If you want a really nice summer citrus try Monsieur Balmain, it's cheap, too.

    You do need to try Bois du Portugal . For dark and woody and unsweet...sorry, baby call, more later
    My Wardrobe
    II est de forts parfums pour qui toute matière/Est poreuse. On dirait qu'ils pénètrent le verre.

  8. #8

    Default Re: New Fragrant (possibly to find a signature one)

    Thanks again for the responses.
    Guerlain's Habit Rouge is difficult to find, but I'll keep this one in mind.

    Same with Adolfo Dominiquez Vetive Hombre L'Occitane's Vetyver and Balmain's Monsieur Balmain..that is to say I cannot find them on Dutch internet shops, which usually means I'm not gonna find them in a regular shop as well.

    Speaking of green scents.
    I wore Lancome's L'aquatonic today and for the 1st time I couldn't stand the smell.
    I came aware of a sharp musky topnote that was piercing through my nose and actually made my nose and throat ache a little
    I didn't spray too much, only 2 spritzs, one at my upperchest and one in my neck and I even received a compliment from a female colleague that I smelled nice, figure that!
    But yes, unfortunately the cologne is too sweet and sharp as well...(it pretty much reminded me of Maxim's) how come I did not notice this before?

    Minotaure (which is a much more heavy and sweet scent) and Mugler's Cologne (which is similar but even sweeter than L'aquatonic), naming only two scents I like and tried, have musk in it as well, but they never stinged my nose unpleasantly.

    Oh well, not going to throw away the bottle yet...
    Last edited by nout; 11th May 2007 at 05:44 PM.

  9. #9

    Default Re: New Fragrant (possibly to find a signature one)

    Well I got me a lot of samples the couple of weeks, very glad it are samples and not (blind-bought) bottles:

    First the samples I didn't like that much

    Kiton men:
    Kinda nice.
    On my skin it is very similar to (a toned-down and lighter) YSL Live Jazz, but instead of the grapefruit in Live Jazz, Kiton has a prominent lemonly note that smells a bit too musky on my skin.

    Guerlain Habit Rouge.
    Oh my god, I don't think I'll ever wear this fragrance...way too strong (even aggressive) and herbal.
    A quality fragrance for sure, nothing synthetical, but definitely not for me.

    Dior Homme.
    Bleh!
    The strong floral note, Iris I believe it is, was supposed to get away very quickly, according to the reviews I read, but on my skin it stays prominent all the way through...

    Vesace Blue Jeans.
    Vanilla and some blueish synthetical note.
    Not offensive in any way, but I don't wanna smell this on my skin

    Versace Baby blue jeans.
    More vanilla or is it vanilla only? I don't sense anything else.
    A dangerous one, if applied too liberal you may get sick of the creamy sweet softness.

    Boss Bottled
    Vanilla and musk, nothing else....maybe a very subltle wood note when I use my imagination.
    Reminiscent of Blue jeans but much much sweeter.
    This one I disliked the most of the samples I tried

    The ones I like:

    Gucci Pour Homme.
    Tam Dao with musk and a tiny drop vanilla added.
    The wood-note is really almost identical to Tam Dao's.

    Bvlgari Pour Homme:
    A very rich, but discrete and sophisticated fragrance.
    It is almost like an updated Gucci Pour Homme, a classic woodsy fragrance but much more complex and smoother, it seems like they paired a classic composition with a more modern aquatic/ozonic technology and it works really very well.
    I'll choose this one over Aqua di Gio any time.
    On my wish list.

    Amor Pour Homme by Cacharel.
    So extremely ordinary, even 'neutral' in a way that I cannot think of one particular fragrance that smells like this one.
    It is like a (perfectly balanced and timeless) average of 1980's (Caractere maybe),1990's (Boss Elements perhaps, XS?) and recent fragrances like Dior's Higher...to my nose it is what Higher tried to be...though I don't exactly know what I mean by that.
    Pretty linear, which is good, you'll get what you smell.
    Very underrated, but not surprisingly: it doesn't stand out, doesn't make a good 1st impression.
    It looks like this one will be my all-round fragrance, I bought a bottle right away (I hope they're not gonna discontinue this one)

    Armani Aqua di Gio
    Got a sample with my bottle Cacharel Amor.
    The 1st time I tried this fragrance on my skin, though I have smelled this one very often on others.
    A quality fragrance for sure, much less synthetical than Azzaro's Chrome, though Chrome has a more unique smell, I never smelled anything that metal-ish.
    Like other aquatics this one smells like tea on my skin, (not the tea-leaves, but the hot drink) a vague lemon tea this one, whereas DKNY for men (I suppose DKNY is an aquatic scent as-well) smells like a mixture of Earl Grey and Ceylon tea on me, which I prefer.
    Because I own Chrome and DKNY for men, I don't have a need for this one.

    Guerlain Vetiver.
    I like this one!
    Not that agressive like Habit Rouge on my skin.
    Not gonna wear this one though, I just don't feel comfortable wearing it, maybe when I'm older and more respected.


    Some I haven't figured out yet:

    Dior Dune
    Like it, very different than anything I ever smelled, but there is something in its sillage which is kinda off-putting, maybe I don't like the musk in the composition, it smells too old lady-like, a bit too creamy.

    Boss Baldessarini.
    Better than Boss Bottled.
    Nothing more I can add right now.

    Gucci Envy.
    No comment yet

    212 Men.
    Similar to Paco Rabane's XS.
    Too sweet, but I'll give this one another try
    Last edited by nout; 4th June 2007 at 06:34 PM. Reason: Automerged Doublepost

Similar Threads

  1. Display Image in Signature
    By Tavorna in forum Community Centre Archive
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: 18th July 2008, 07:44 PM
  2. Help find a new scent in the same class?
    By nitto in forum Male Fragrance Discussion
    Replies: 19
    Last Post: 30th August 2005, 03:34 AM
  3. Signature scent, sort of?
    By Tuner_Watson in forum Male Fragrance Discussion
    Replies: 20
    Last Post: 11th August 2005, 10:45 PM
  4. I Find Havana!!
    By Ballardbeau in forum Male Fragrance Discussion
    Replies: 25
    Last Post: 21st July 2005, 12:03 PM
  5. Finally Found a Signature Scent!
    By rjrober22 in forum Male Fragrance Discussion
    Replies: 19
    Last Post: 11th March 2005, 05:19 PM

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •