For some reason, her Les Petites is really beautiful to me. I like the Fleurs de Chocolat and Bois du Chocolat, too. I've tried so many over the years I can't keep them all straight, LOL! I did go through a bottle of Beach Roses, maybe a year ago. It was a great Autumn scent for me, but this Autumn I'm preferring sweeter scents. I would definitely love your version of Beach Roses!