It has been my experience that while giving/getting a gift of fragrance is right up my alley, most people are really picky and no matter how hard I try, they don't like what I pick. Oh, they will be polite and tell me how wonderful it is but then they never wear it. Now, if she told you exactly what she likes, why not get her one of the Creeds? There is almost nothing worse that seeing a gift bottle languishing away, covered in dust because it wasn't to their liking. Why not take her to the store and spend a couple of hours trying perfumes and while you are at it...take notes! That way she will get exactly what she wants.
By the way, your choices sound fantastic (except for the Amouage...but that's just me).