I posed the question some time ago about wine and scents, as for me there is an influence on what scent you wear and what a glass of wine might taste like! (It's true!!).
However, for cooking/baking... difficult question, because I like to cook too (not so much into baking!) - but I guess it will depend on what you're cooking! Though you didn't really say what you might be cooking, but if I assume it might be ham with cloves, I think the Arabie would be very nice (I don't own it, but have sniffed it... and it will be on my buy list soon! ). I haven't smelled the others you mentioned, but in my wardrobe, I would go with Carlos Santa for men too - it reminds me of baking apple pies!