That was quite an epic review, and a very nice one at that. I too am a fan of Cool Water and thought that your review did justice to its appearance on the fragrance scene. It was the AdG of its generation, ubiquitous and somewhat groundbreaking, taking into account what was available on the mainstream market at the time. However, there is one item in the Davidoff's closet that mainstream fans might not pick up on, but "those in the know" might find issue with (and I use the word "issue" in the lightest terms possible), and that is the existence of a gent named "Green Irish Tweed". His being eliminates the "uniqueness" of Cool Water, taking into account that the latter was heavily influenced by the former, much like Unforgivable was (ahem) influenced by Millesime Imperial.
Other than that, I found your review quite thorough and very enjoyable. (And it makes me want to wear Cool Water again.) Nice job!