Thread: Knockoff fever!!
I'm glad the knockoffs are out there. Sure many smell blatantly NOT like the original, but some are pretty darn close. Let the eilitests spend the big bucks----we all turn to ash in the end--enjoy it all now.
I did find a Chanel Egoiste knockoff in a place that had a whole list of knockoffs to create. I found an Angel knockoff at Walgreens that smells pretty good. Hmm what was the name of that chocolate Axe?
Most noses in here know the difference, but the vox populi might not even know the difference.
Last edited by JickyMan; 20th February 2008 at 02:38 AM.
Your nostrils, which will dilate immesurably in unspeakable contentment, in motionless ecstasy, will ask nothing better for space, for they will be full of fragrance, as if perfumes and incense; for they will be glutted with complete happiness, like angels who dwell in the peace and magnificence of pleasent heaven.
(From Maldoror by Comte de Lautreamont)
Funny. I just picked up a knock off of drakkar noir for kicks. It was 1.99!
Unfortunately, after trying to smell the others (a fake one of polo green and ck one), I now have a cloud following me around that smells like a medicine cabinet.. or an old band aid. I tried to wash it off at the nearest bathroom I could find with this soap that smelled like bubble gum, and now there's a cloud following me that smells like a sweetly rancid band aid
Help! Someone call the ambulance!
Uh.. whoops. Just noticed how old this thread is. I'm doomed now for sure! If anyone finds a corpse smelling like a sweet, rancid band aid, tell my parents I loved them.
Back in the late 90's I bought a knockoff of Tommy called Johnnie! It smelled similar, but you could tell it was a really cheap imitation.
Some reflections on knock offs...
1. Take similar fragrances, are they knock offs? As per mentions in several threads and reviews, I am thinking of Creed's Orange Spice and YSL's Kouros, or Bond's Grand Jones and Paco Rabanne's pour Homme.
2. Odd as it may seem, there are knock-offs that are still true to the original formulation of the blends "inspiring" them, the original ones being a pale version of what they used to be - either lacking complexity or longevity.
3. There are knock-offs that are somehow different and / or improved versions of the original scents. They might as well claim being a separate entity.
4. There are knock offs of discontinued scents. Down here, there are very inexpensive versions of Zino and Montana (Red), which, BTW, are FBW - in the second case, privided you are not too picky, for they fall in category # 2 (not exaclty the same, but damned enjoyable).
5. One last reflection: are there knock-offs of niche brands like Lutens or Goutal? LOL
I love a good quality knockoff, for exactly the reason Pollux cited - they can be better than the original OR duplicate a prior, superior formulation of another scent.
Perfect example: Akthar Noir is a knockoff of the original formulation of Drakkar Noir, and an outstanding one at that! The reason it's great is because it smells exactly like the original formula of Drakkar Noir from the 80s, with all the sillage and longevity of the original. Plus it's an eau de parfum! I bought five bottles of it, it's so good ($3 too!).
Check out my blog Pour Monsieur, a no-nonsense guide to men's fragrances:
Any fragrance that should not be worn in public, should be worn in public.
As to 5 (in post #37), there it Tobaco Latino, which seems to me to be an attempt to make a cheap Tabaco Vanille type of frag. Here is the blurb on it:
"TOBACCO LATINO, the sweet and familiar aroma of the famous Cuban cigars. The base note, in which the rustic freshness of laurel, and clary sage is complemented by a touch of rum, and leads to a delicately flowery heart of lily of the valley, and freesia, complemented by the fruity tones of coconut, and raspberry. The richly woody background notes of vetiver, sandalwood, and cedarwood highlight the tobacco note, sweetened with a touch of honey."
It's not niche quality, and it's sort of a toned down B*Men, with spices removed and a nice dry tobacco leaf added (sort of like an unsmoked cigarette). It's light but lasts reasonably well, especially on clothing. However, it smells great, though that may be because I like the notes and construction.
Visit my huge swap page: http://www.basenotes.net/threads/211...-ml-Gotham-etc
Or visit my Sales page: http://www.basenotes.net/threads/211...o-make-offers!
Samples, etc. for Sale at my Crystal Flacon page: http://flacon.ambaric.net/viewtopic.php?t=282
My fragrance blog: http://bigslyfragrance.wordpress.com/
I just came back from mall where I found section with nice knockoff fragrances. There were like 3 different knockoffs of Fahrenheit varying in price from 3 to 10 euros per 2.5 Oz. Funny is that closest to original was the cheapest one (I sampled that one yesterday and it actually lasted like 4 hours, and in very close to skin mode 12 hours...). There were also knockoffs of Coco Mademoiselle, Angel, 2 versions of Acqua Di Gio, 2 versions of Le Male, 2 versions of Light Blue Pour Femme, etc. I checked where they come from and most of them were Made in Poland but one brand was from UAE. For average price of 5 euros per 3.4oz bottle they smelled very nice but I guess that they wont last as much as original.
TOP 3 hot weather:
1. Gucci Pour Homme II
2. Creed Millesime Imperial
3. Lalique Encre Noire
TOP 3 cold weather:
1. Dior Homme
2. Eau Des Baux
3. L'Instant de Guerlain Pour Homme Extreme
My friend's mother had a knock-off of Eternity called... Endless Fun.
She bought it because the name is hilarious.
Amongst the knock off , copies or whatever you like to call them is quite a decent Barbershop fragrance.
In a Green Box Called " EAD BRIGHT " its very potent and a couple of sprays to the chest in the morning and you will have a Rive Gauche ( ish )
scent wafting around you all day.
I have bought a lot worse for £30 plus so if you like Barbershop , give it a try for 99p.
I just saw 3 at Target yesterday. They all said "if you like ___, then you will love _xyz_."
They looked like Axe cans, and were rips of Drakkar Noir, AdG, and Fierce.
All for $3 each.
They smelled pretty close, albeit more synthetic.
About what I was expecting. Worth a gym bag addition.
Crest? Is that Creed's take on toothpaste?
We have local shop here that has 3 long-desks covered in knock-offs. From Aquatic Di Joe -I believe that was the name- to DK One
360 red - acqua di gio. 360 white - jpg
As someone mentioned earlier about Australia we have loads of knock-offs in the 'If you love X, you'll love this.' style. Sometimes I sniff them. Sadly though I'm rarely that familiar with anything popular enough that people make knock offs of it, and I don't like to buy knock-offs. If I want super-cheap fragrances, and sometimes I do I think there are plenty of originals which are surprisingly good.
Does my bottle of New Harlem count as a knock off of Rochas Man? I've never smelled Rochas Man so I hope not. I mostly got New Harlem because I don't want a butt-plug shaped bottle. Also the packaging is plush. Still if it's a copy that's just dreck and really confirms why I dislike Bond, although I can't say I dislike the smell. I'm rather fond of it actually.
I recently purchased a few so called knock offs from Wal-Mart.
Clasic Match - Polo Green
Electric Blue - Bleu De Chanel
Vault - Armani Code
All three of these smell pretty damn close to the original nor do they suffer from the to much alcohol problem that most knock offs suffer from. I am not ashamed for purchasing them and I although they will not be the fragrances I am going to reach for if I am going out on a date or out doing something special, I have no problems with wearing them for everyday use. I mostly keep them in my car as emergency fragrances though.
Living each day one spray at a time
I mentioned in a recent thread of mine a perfume cheapie called Roxane. It's an excellent copy of Chanel no.5. In fact I actually find it somehow better than no.5. I also mentioned the Lidl discount supermarket release, "Suddenly Madame Glamour". This has received a huge amount of publicity and praise for its high standard of quality. For €5 it is on a par with Coco Mademoiselle and in blind tests many people actually rated it the better of the two fragrances.
RARE PERFUME DECANTS - FACEBOOK (closed group) - Hundreds of ultra rare extraits available, including Djedi and Nombre Noir.
& Surrati Tom Oud - they do a lot, but this seems to be the most mentioned.
I use knock offs for the restroom spray...pure oro for one million is dead on.