Givenchy Pi, Ralph Lauren Romance Silver, Armani code...come to mind right off since you like varvatos, Allure, Gaultier.
You might also like bulgari black if you like black jeans...both have that black rubber note or tar note, whichever.
Also look into Santa Maria Novella Musk(Muschino)...can check her out at Lafco.com...this is a real rich, beautifully crafted frag.
If you like Kors, you might like Bogart pour homme
if you like lolita lempika, hanae mori try minotaure by paloma picasso
You also may like Vera wang for men...has a lovable sweet herbaceous drydown...its awesome but im sure you have already tried this one working at Sephora.
Hope these suggestions help.