I think it's a toss up between the AA and the Egoiste. Hypnose doesn't come close in my book.
I don't think the three are even in the same ballpark. AA is dense amber(gris) and sensual with some darkness. Very powerful and fairly linear yet still amazing.
Egoiste is a tad transparent to me with a long, lovely dry down and it's got that rose in the middle that's just awesome and the vanilla, sandalwood base that is one of the best in men's fragrance IMO. It's slightly sweet but not too much so. Also a powerhouse but not as much so as AA on my skin.
Hypnose is a decent modern fragrance but shares nothing with the above except some sweetness but it gets to the point of cloying on me. It's got this density that reminds me of Le Male and Body Kouros, two scents that I got rid of as fast as I bought. I don't find Hypnose to be very original and I wouldn't mention it in the same breath as AA or the original Egoiste.
I think both AA and Egoiste merit testing and owning. Egoiste can still be found on the net but I understand it will be exclusive to Chanel boutiques soon. AA is from a Creed retailer or E-Bay of course. Please report back if you check them out.