Where did you find this one to test?!
I wonder if the negative responses are because many claim it was reformulated in the 90's to a shadow of it's former self? I've never had the chance to test either one.
I almost ordered it blind because of my love for Arome 3 and Chevalier but have been hesitating because of some negative comments in the directory.
The Perfumed Court actually has the original extrait in stock for sampling.