Now, do NOT overspray Nightflight. That fragrance has some serious sillage. You are only experiencing nose fatigue with several of your fragrances. One way to avoid that is to spray on your chest and not on your neck.
I suggest you to try Egoiste. Elegant Vanilla roses and sandalwood (though I can Bareilly get sandalwood). Alternatives good fragrances are Code and Varvatos Vintage.
I also recommend you to try the Dreamer, when I first tried it I though of a mixture of Nightflight and Bulgary black. Also try Fragonard’s concerto or Clairborne Sport.