For my money I would stick with the original or the EDP version of the original. But it comes down to personal taste. I think you may get samples of the other Gendarme's from their website. A small expense instead of a blind buy. I didn't care for Sky either. It smelled exactly like Gendarme(Seven Deadly Sins)Sloth in my opinion. But I really do like the original and EDP. I am curious about Green and even Mojo which I haven't sampled as of yet. Bottom line... get samples whenever possible. By the way, the Gendarme soap is very clean and fresh smelling too.