Depends on what you like. They are completely different kind of fragrances. If you want something safe, then go with D&G. If you want to be a bit daring, then go with NR. I would pick NR. But the chances of someone not liking NR are much higher than not liking D&G. By te same token, then chances of someone falling in love with NR are much higher than falling in love with D&G as well.
fresh & subtle = D&G
not so fresh earthy & not so subtle = NR.