I remember I was in the subway some years ago, and a girl next to me asked me what scent I was wearing. It was L'instant pour homme by Guerlain. We chatted a bit, it was fun. I remember she said it was "heavenly".
Now I get compliments mostly from my girlfriend, which is basically the only girl I deal with (I work at home and I am not that socialite). She likes -- and uses - Dior Homme, and loves Geranium pour monsieur by Malle.