I love Straight to Heaven and A Taste of Heaven. I can find things boozy and woody more afforable than STH. ATOH is just a more refined eloquent Caron pour Homme. At $225.00 for 50ml they need to be unique enough for me to shell out the bucks. The By Kilian program of after you shell out $225.00 you can get a refill for $115.00 is a joke for me. After 50ml of 90% of most frags I'm already tired of it and have moved on to something else. By kilian is marketing there product to "signature scent" people who will wear there stuff for 20 years. That customer is not me. So I think the By Kilian line in general has nice frags - the 1st rate ingredients being a major plus in my book - still has not got me to buy a bottle.