Very good question. I'm sure you'll get a range of answers. I really find that most vanilla scents, even scents with a small amount of vanilla in them, don't suit me at all. Certainly this is true in the case of the CSP Vanilla line.
But there are a couple of CSP scents that I love! Admittedly they are male-oriented. They are dry, aromatic, woody. But some women like this sort of scent to wear too. Here's what I like (I've reviewed these, if you want more info):
Barbier des Iles