I know what you're thinking guys...this is a woman's fragrance, right? Believe me. You guys can wear this one.
All of you amber enthusiasts out there - check this out: This one starts out soft and cushiony amber, very toned down with just a hint of sweetness. The first time I tested it I expected much more spice from it, but I soon realized that this was just my scent association working in my mind. Amber Sultan has kind of made it easy to love an amber with a bucket load of spices added. When I smell an amber without it, my nose almost feels like there's an empty space in the air.
The ylang ylang is almost undetectable - which is fine with me, since most of the time this note smells like cold cream to my nose. I do smell a light floral touch in the middle notes (rose?) but it's dusted with cinnamon. This part reminds me of Bois de Paradis by Parfums Delrae, just not so green. Then the scent ends on a blanket of sandalwood and vanilla.
I think it's nice to see a department store brand like Lauder branching out in the amber category, even if it is a 'safe' amber. Even still, the blending and ingredients smell top notch. I could easily see me testing this blind and guessing that this was a L'Artisan Parfumeur release. It's quality is that evident. Lauder also has a parfum / extrait version of this, which I'd love to smell (and its likely more resinous) but it's slightly out of my price range ($300 / 1 oz)
For fans of Blue Amber by Montale or Ambre Precieux by MPG who are looking for a more accessible amber for the fall/winter season - give PCAYY a try. No one will know that you're wearing a woman's fragrance.
I am fascinated by amber because it was an accord I initially struggled to detect. Reviews would mention it's "radiant warmth" and I just couldn't get it.
Since testing Amber Sultan twice it's "burned" in my mind as "the" amber reference so I surely understand your association with it.
With all the recent talk in the forums re: Black Orchid I'm keen to try "women's" frags with an open mind. BTW - I love NR for Her
Conscience is what hurts when everything else feels so good.
Cool mp23 .. to my nose Ambre Sultan is far from an amber benchmark, but this new EL with amber at the forefront cushioned by light florals and sandalwood/vanilla...is the amber note less forceful and resinous than in Ambre Precieux ?
I was not crazy about this one. Maybe it is the testers.
I absolutely love Amber Sultan and for a sweeter amber I would pick Ambre Fetiche by Annick Goutal.
I don't think I am smelling the same fragrance! I have a manufacturer sample, and it really smells like vanilla cake batter and hairspray on me. But then again, I had trouble with Sensuous--didn't get the sweet woods in that one, just a nasty cinnamon wax candle.
I don't think my nose is broken, lol But it does make me wonder what's going on, especially given that I have good luck with many of the other EL scents.
Thanks for the review Mike - I'm a big time amber slut. Is it exclusive to one store, or can I find it at all Estee Lauder counters?
Another day, another Easter egg hunt!
Last edited by Kevin Guyer; 31st October 2008 at 04:33 AM.
This sounds pleasant... and perfect timing too, i'm on an Amber high as of now
PVC and Leather. A Chain and a feather
Only recently, have I branched out into testing other ambers, since Ambre Sultan had me so enraptured before I was happy with just that one. A sweeter amber is not necessarily what I think I am looking for, even though I think PCAYY is sweet.
I remember your comments about this scent on the women's board, where we discussed the pros and cons of this and Youth Dew Amber Nude, the discontinued Tom Ford/Estee Lauder scent. IMO they are worlds apart, when it comes to amber.
Tried the parfum version at NM yesterday. Extremely smooth, slightly sweet, and well balanced - sort of a vanilla amber tea, a tea without any smoke, that is. The amber isn't syrupy and resinous; the ylang ylang adds a custard like richness, giving it a quality approaching niche. Perhaps it's similar to Yves Rocher's Voille de Ambre - a sheer take on amber, but without that slightly medicinal harshness that VdA opens with. Nice, if you find Ambre Sultan and Ambre Precieux too thick and you want something smooth. None of the Estee Lauder chemical warfare, house notes lurking anywhere, thank god.
Last edited by Kevin Guyer; 2nd November 2008 at 01:37 PM.
I went to Nordstrom's yesterday, and they had a tester of the EDP, so I thought I would try it to be sure my sample wasn't off. Still got the vanilla cake batter at first, and the hairspray note didn't seem as bad this time. I tried to get another sample, but they were already out...
NM had 3 different testers out. The perfume is the one with the jeweled top. Saks and NM always have testers of the Guerlain parfums out, too. But those are always in the squat, ugly, little bottles.