I don't know Baume du Doge, so I have to skip that one, but from the remaining two I choose Winter Star everytime.
Amazing scent. Totally unique. Must be smelled, because it's too hard to describe.
Don't overspray it, because a couple of tiny dots is enough, and then go out for a walk when it's cold, or even better, really freezing outside. That's the best way to experience it.