They are all excellent, but my first choice would be the Chanel.
Antaeus all the way!
Thread: Antaeus/VanCleef PH/Trussardi
Time to use some of those online vouchers gratefully received as Christmas gifts.
Looking to purchase either Antaeus, Van Cleef Pour Homme or Trussardi - as you can see I favour the discreet, subtle fragrances! I am looking for a strong, masuline, (possibly even dark and mysterious) scent with good longevity, sillage optional.
From looking through reviews on BN, it seems that there are many similarities between these fragrances, with regular comparisons from different users.
Can get only one for the moment, which would be my best bet?
They are all excellent, but my first choice would be the Chanel.
Antaeus all the way!
Two roads diverged in a yellow wood, and sorry I could not travel both and be one traveler, long I stood and looked down one as far as I could to where it bent in the undergrowth; Then took the other, as just as fair, ...... I shall be telling this with a sigh somewhere ages and ages hence: Two roads diverged in a wood, and I -- I took the one less traveled by, and that has made all the difference. - Robert Frost
I agree... Antaeus is a must.
Antaeus or a vintage bottle of Van Cleef (it does not say "pour homme" on those). A vintage bottle of antaeus would be even better .
II est de forts parfums pour qui toute matičre/Est poreuse. On dirait qu'ils pénčtrent le verre.
if it`s Trussardi Inside you meen, i will highly recomend it!
Both, Antaeus and Van Cleef & Arpels pour Homme! They are good and different enough - the latter as possibly the best leather-chypre around and the first as the finest woody oriental - to own a bottle of each!
Anteus is more floral, the actual VC&A more leatherish, Trussardi is a extremily similar to VC&A with pungent middle notes similar, IMHO, to those I recognize in Old Spice, that in my ignorance I think it might be poor quality sandalwood.
I would go for Antaeus, then VC&A. Still, both are excelent choices you won't regret having in your wardrobe.
I believe that all of these, unfortunately, have been reformulated. Of the reformulations, Antaeus's is the best, and Antaeus remains a very good fragrance. I've seen a a thread a while ago that the original VC&A is again available in addition to the reformulated version that has been around for a while and is an ehhh. I haven't investigated the "new-old" VC&R yet, but I hope the return to the old is true. As for Trussardi, don't even think about the reformulation of the original masterpiece - it's sweet and annoying and not even a shadow of its former self IMO.
Last edited by foetidus; 15th January 2009 at 11:35 PM.
Van Cleef and Arpels is the best option for me, very masculine....feels like a billionaire fragance.
Anteus is too feminine......And Trussardi is not my cup of tea for the moment.
"Burn their homes and churches.Then see if they will not laugh, sing and pray again.
For when two of them meet anywhere in the world, see if they will not create a new Armenia."
Using: Antaeus, The Dreamer, Eau Sauvage and Voyage d Hermes
Wishing: Tuscan Soul by Ferragamo and Concentré d Orange Verte
I find Antaeus super macho on my skin. Nothing feminine about it. The original is terrific and although I have not worn the reformulation, it's good judging by the members responses.
I say it's the best of the 3 and the most bang for the buck as well.
Last edited by AromiErotici; 16th January 2009 at 12:38 AM.
to my nose
Van Cleef & Arpel pour Homme wins hands down.
It wins by a large margin in terms of the qualities you described. It is WAYYYYY more masculine and pownerful, yet in a VERY clean, classy, pleasant way.
Antaeus, on the other hand, doesn NOT smell masculine to me. It is a VERY GOOD fragrance -- unique, complex, sophisticated. Very inky as well -- like I have a leak of the old foundation pen. It stands on its own, but no where near VC&A.
Last edited by abc1234; 17th January 2009 at 12:58 AM.
Another Antaeus vote for me. I have a 10mL decant that I'm currently scraping bottom with, looking to get a bottle. Trussardi Uomo I didn't care for, traded away soon after picking it up. Haven't tried the VC.
Antaeus has never struck me as feminine.
Antaeus for sure with me.....The others are classic for sure.....I would go with Antaeus.
They are all great scents but Van Cleef PH is perfection to my nose.
I am Antaeus-wearing woman, hey, it's just so heady and lush!
Those three comprise my three fave men's fragrance of all time, so I had to reply.
I'm assuming you mean the Trussardi Trussardi in the black croc bottle. I'd have to rule it out first, as the women's version so far exceeds it (and makes a fine maculine, btw), and this gives it a weakness, though it still rocks. And I vote, based on you description, for the Van Cleef. It's so dark, so super manly...and leathery! Also, Antaeus isn't leathery. The other two are extreme leathers. Maybe a consideration?
Try it and ... Quorum ... A deep dark masculine fragrance !
You can get Quorum for little money on line... So buy that and Antaeus and you will be good to go...
Thanks for all advice. Narrowed down to either Antaeus or Van Cleef & Arpels Pour Homme based on replies.
Tested Antaeus today in local shop, very impressive and quite intoxicating mix of florals and beeswax with hint of leather. Definitely something I would enjoy, but maybe not as blatantly masculine (yet anyway) as I might have expected.
Unfortunately, haven't beeen able to sample VCA - so opinion based solely on opinions in BN. I am still intrigued by it, but not sure if its a good blind buy.
As a by-the-way, have found both online at roughly the same price, so cost not an issue.
I donīt know VanCleef PH - is it not an early fragrance from J.C ellena ?
foetidus i donīt find Trussardi Uomo sweet. I find Antaeus is sweeter than Trussardi uomo (which is available very cheap 20 € for 100 ml). But i didnīt test them at the same time. We had november 2008 a topic here about the strongest-manliest scent were Trussardi Uomo had a lot of votes.
"Wow, I've never smelled anything like that before."
In this order:
Vintage Trussardi Uomo (darkest of them all)
Vintage VC &A
VC & A
Last edited by tvlampboy; 16th January 2009 at 08:32 PM.
Peggy: "Right now, we have to get to the mental institution. Something terrible has happened."
Peggy: "Brother Boy has tried to kill himself. He jumped out of his bedroom window."
Latrelle: "Isn't he only on the second floor?"
Peggy: "Yes, but he hit his head on a lawn gnome."
Fr. Sordid Lives: The Series
"Live, live, live! Life is a banquet, and most poor suckers are starving to death."
I find that I reach more often for VC&A, most probably because I own it longer than I have had Antaeus and I know better what to expect. IMO it's a bit darker than Antaeus - which I like, but not to say that A is not good! Both deserve a special place in my wardrobe :wave:
BTW I got them both blind and don't regret it at all. I appreciate fragrances that don't apologise for being strong and out there.
I'm unable to comment on the Trussardi
All three of them are just GRAND, by, out of these three, Antaeus remains my favorite, closely followed by both Trussardi and Van Cleef and Arpels PH, honorably and equally sharing a more than remarkable and truly successfully and rightfully gained second spot, with just very little distance from the top ranking.
The vintage Trussardi Uomo was strong and manly - Check out my review of it in the directory. Then I bought the reissued one and I have no desire to wear it - it's just too sweet to me now. I have used up my decant of the vintage so I can't compare them directly and I am going by memory but what I get with my new bottle is sweet and superficial.
The best smelling boyfriend I ever had wore Antaeus.
If you can get the New-Old VC&A please do. The reformulated one does not compare.
Otherwise, i would say Antaeus (as presently formulated).
ointments and perfume delight the heart....
VC&A - good stuff
Antaeus - "That smells very soft and gentle." Comment I got from a female. Perhaps not what you're yearning after right now.
Trußardi - has a lot in common with VC&A, but rougher, less well blended, in my opinion.
A little bit disappointing to hear that these have all been reformulated from their original status. Having read all about how great they are, it seems that they are now each somewhat of a lesser scent that what they once were, with Antaues being the best of the reformulations, but still somewat short of the original blend.
Two other fragrances have been mentioned to me - Quorum and Montana Pour Homme (Red). These both are certainly cheaper than my original selections, but can they hold their own in this (once) exalted company. I did try Quorum in my youth, remember it as being very rich but somewhat raw, never tried Maontana Red. Any views?