Not in my experience.
Thread: Bel Ami and Antaeus. Brothers?
I think Hermes Bel Ami is a lighter version of CHANEL Antaeus.. Agreed??
Not in my experience.
I don't get much resemblance. The vintage of both are more leather-heavy (and vintage Antaeus is less powdery). So you can get some similarities in them.
WHICH Bel Ami are you referring to? the reformulated Bel Ami is a totally different scent than the original.
either way....i don't think either are similar to Antaeus.....very different scents IMO.
Both are very masculine, but Antaeus is of the 'aromatic' variety (herbs, lavender), and Bel Ami is more of the 'leather chypre' variety. Both great, but not alike.
Not at all: spicy top notes proper of Bel Ami are absent in Antaeus, whose top notes are clearly floral. They share common base notes in terms of the leather notes present, but do take in mind there are still differences between these ones too.
I'm not active on the boards but boy do I lurk!
Rather than create a whole new thread I'd rather revive this one to get your current opinions on these two fragrances.
I have tried both Antaeus (decant) and Bel Ami (small sample) and I like them both, but can't decide which to get a full bottle (current formulation).
Here's the caveat: Antaeus floral opening is somewhat challenging to my nose and Bel Ami's cumin note is tough to digest at first yet their drydown is to my liking.
So, which do you prefer and why? Please kindly expound.
Remember that while it is perfectly acceptable to criticize the content of a post - criticizing the poster is not.
Mean spirited, nasty, snide, sarcastic, hateful, and rude individuals on Basenotes don't warrant or deserve my or other Basenoters' acknowledgement or respect.
I'd probably go with Antaeus, but I haven't smelled the current version.
As mentioned, both are excellent and it's hard to go wrong.
Both are excellent in their vintage formulations. Antaeus has a stronger personality. It reminds me of older gentlemen I sometimes see at airports that wear Tweed sportscoats and are properly dressed like they are still in the 1970's.
Bel Ami is more understated, it is quietly charming.
I slightly prefer Antaeus.
Bel Ami is my first love, current formulation has yet to be sniffed. Antaeus, current is very good scent, Vintage is a superb.
Scarcity is an illusion. Unlearn it.
Thank you all for your responses! It is indeed a tough choice. I failed to mention that I own Bel Ami Vetiver - I like that sort of brown/green smell in the first stages and then that vetiver pops in the drydown.
Would it be redundant to own the current Bel Ami?
Prefer Bel Ami, and, worth having it even with BAV IMO
...it's more the other way around: Antaeus is the frisky young colt and Bel Ami the dark old grumbler...
The bee's wax accord sets Antaeus apart from Bel Ami or indeed any other frag i know.
Both are very good though. If forced, i would choose Antaeus.
ointments and perfume delight the heart....
In their current formulations I'd surely pick Bel Ami instead, which has surely been watered down and made a bit more flat, but just that, it's still nice and still has Bel Ami footprint. Nothing closer to the disgusting mess they did with Antaeus (I know many still appreciate the current version; I find it screechy and horrid).
Last edited by Colin Maillard; 24th September 2016 at 11:13 AM.
My fragrance reviews | Ye Olde Civet Cat
A magnificent, raw but refined opening of musky castoreum, warm but dry and really close to leather (like in Knize Ten and other classics), but gently softened by aromatic woods, spices and silky colourful hints of flowers. Animalic but friendly and elegant, it has a typical fougère "gloominess" but it also appears more "young", relaxed and modern than most of other more classic and austere fougères, and also more sophisticated and sharp. The evolution is quite predictable, as it remains a castoreum-leather smoky accord, just drier and lighter as hours pass. Restrained and noble, always without being too shady or heavy, rather keeping it slightly "airy" and more lively thanks to rose, jasmine and fresh tasty herbs like thyme and sage. Versatile, classy, cozy, masculine. Timeless classic!
Seeking: Bottles/decants : of Pomegranate Noir, Midnight in Paris EDP, Feeling Man, Essence of John Galliano, Azzaro pour Homme (vintage),...etc.
Seeking decant/sample of PdE Ambre Russe, Jil Sander Feeling Man, Comme des Garcons 2 Man, Giorgio VIP, ....etc. I have samples to swap.
Please PM me !
Wearing BAV today and think I'm leaning towards Bel Ami. Tried Antaeus last night and feel it loses direction/balance in the drydown - the heart is pleasing though.
Last edited by fragsrock; 25th September 2016 at 12:33 AM.
Vintage vs vintage, Bel Ami by a small margin
Current vs current, Bel Ami by a much wider margin
I really like vintage Anateus, I love vintage Bel Ami.
Vintage Bel Ami is a top 5 fragrance for me while vintage Anateus is a top 15. It really comes down to uniqueness... There's nothing like vintage Bel Ami, and if there is, I'd love to find it
Wit that said, both are great fragrances in their own right but very different.
I have found the paradox, that if you love until it hurts, there can be no more hurt, only more love.
Smelled the latest iteration of Antaeus again today at Saks. This smells like a fragrance that was a Oh Heck No in 1960, that they pulled out to show me today....
Bel Ami can come across dated as well, but at least you get the sense it's well done... no matter when it came out. Not the case with Antaeus. Bel Ami still wins this one still IMO.
I've decided Bel Ami is a better fit for my taste and bought it. I'll keep playing around with my Antaeus decant as I have a feeling a FB will eventually end up in my hands.
Only smelled the current versions but to me Antaeus has a very prominent animalic aspect that is absent in Bel Ami
I can provide decants of anything I post about!
Bel Ami in vintage version, shaker bottle, is one of my biggest fragrance loves - it trumps even vintage Antaeus, which I love to pieces as well. Tough choice, I get it, but not for me - Bel Ami wins by a decent margin (not that I'd part with my old bottle of Antaeus anytime soon, though!!)
CURRENTLY ACTIVE SPLITS:
TOM FORD Private Blend: Bois Marocain Reserve 2016 / Ombré Leather 16 / Vert d'Encens / Vert De Fleur
Comme des Garcons: Wonderoud ..... Amouage: Myths Man / Beloved Man / Interlude Man
Frapin: Passion Boisée ..... Valentino: Uomo Intense ..... Gerlain: Habit Rouge Dress Code
Le Labo: Thé Noir 29 / Poivre 23 ..... Christian Dior La Collection Privée: Vetiver / Oud Ispahan / Gris Montaigne
Maison Francis Kurkdjian: APOM pour homme / Cologne Pour Le Soir / Lumière Noire Pour Homme / Amyris Homme / OUD Satin Mood
Roja Dove: Amber Aoud Crystal Parfum / Aoud Crystal Parfum / Scandal Pour Homme EdP / Danger Pour Homme Parfum
Creed Les Royales Exclusives: Jardin d'Amalfi / Royal Mayfair / Spice and Wood / Pure White Cologne
I own both in current formulations and I can't say what one I like better they are both amazing and evoke different emotions it's like asking whats better cake or ice cream.....BUY BOTH!!! If I had a gun to my head I would probably take Antaeus.
Psalm 118:1 Give thanks to the Lord, for he is good;
his love endures forever.