OMG I've been jonesing for Madeline for some time. Maybe we can start a letter writing campaign to Serena imploring her to bring it back (I've never smelled it, but loving gourmands and vanilla, it seems right up my alley)!!
I've tried Noel Blanc--it's lovely but a very cool gourmand. Not warm at all--I think it was the ozonic notes that chilled it out for me.
I have Amande Sucre and I love it. A very strongly almond scent, sweet and warm.
I also have Turkish Vanilla which is a terrific vanilla-centric scent. It smells musky though musk isn't listed, and reminds me a bit of Love's True Bluish Light. PM me if you want to try these before you buy! I also have Loukhoum, Milk, Ambra Tibet and Madame X (woah...seems I'm becoming an Ava Luxe groupie!).