Exfoliant cleanser? Neutrogena or Biore make decent ones, no need to spend a ton of money.
If you're looking for a moisturizer or unscented aftershave balm, try Art of Shaving. Great stuff.
Shave cream? Proraso is tough to beat. (I'm guessing you;re using a shaving brush?) e^Shave is good, Truefitt & Hill is great, but expensive. Geo. F. Trumper makes good stuff, as does Taylor of Old Bond Street.
For masks? Just order a pound of green french clay and make your own with water. Or use a lavender or rose hydrosol to perk it up.