I much prefer Lyric Woman - it's certainly more substantial and fuller than the men's version. The jammy creaminess, which works with the rose accord, is simply delicious. However, I'm not sure if its longevity is adequate for its retail price. In addition, there's something disturbingly synthetic in the drydown - I need more time to ponder on this stage but there's definitely something not quite right. Regardless of this reservation, it's currently my favourite Amouage and is a big improvement on the recently re-issued Ubar.