Snob?! What kind of snob?

[Trebor]

There's been various threads about niche snobs but I consider myself to be more of a perfume concentration snob. In other words, if it's not an EDP I'm not interested. I know there's no hard and fast rule concerning concentrations but maybe I'm not the only one here. Personally, I blame it on my skin chemistry...

I'd like to hear your thoughts regarding this subject.

[Basteri]

if I read the words "extreme" or "concentree" or " double" I am there.

[jenson]

i love both Edt's and Edp's ...and with Habit Rouge even Edc. but, i see wht you mean Trebor..serge lutens which comes in EDP form has a certain feel to it (smoother, denser), so are some of the PG's et al...but then there are scents like New York, Havana Reserva, Ungaro I & II, Leonard Ph..which are edts and are still delivers a fuller feel. so, for me, it doesnt matter much as long as the scent delivers...

one eg. i'd like to site is: i like Habit Rouge Edc a lot better than it's Edt form...never tested the Edp so wouldnt know...wht im comign to is, some scents smell better in a particular concentration and thts wht matters the most....

[Bartlebooth]

I think it might depend on the skin type. There are a number of fragrances where I will actually pick the EDT rather than the EDP, simply because it works better with me.

I certainly would not call anyone a snob for acquiring solely EDPs, just pernickety

[jacona]

If given the choice, I'll take an EDP over an EDT. There are a few scents that are great in EDT, Habanita (for me) comes to mind, but usually I prefer EDP.

[perfaddict]

if I read the words "extreme" or "concentree" or " double" I am there.

Yep! If that is "marketing", it works on me

[Basteri]

seriously guys, dont we all want the extra kick?

[irish]

seriously guys, dont we all want the extra kick?

no.

I would like to believe that I really do not care about the concentration of a certain fragrance, but, at least statistically, I tend to prefer EdTs over EdPs. For fragrances where two versions are available, I generally find the edt better blended and a bit more sophisticated. This is specially true for houses like Guerlain and Chanel. If I want longevity, then I carry an atomizer. If I want silage I just spray more. Granted, not everybody will like this approach, but the way I see it, once I have the EdP there is not much I can do to make it smell just as good as the EdT.

As for snobs, I present you David Hume:

"A good palate is not tried by strong flavors; but by a mixture of small ingredients, where we are still sensible of each part, notwithstanding its minuteness and its confusion with the rest..."*

*OK I promise, this really is the last time I post that quote.

[somnambulist07]

I'll take my Hugo Boss Energise Eau de Toilette and be a very happy man. No snobbery here...

[Pour_Monsieur]

If there is a stronger concentration option I will always chose that over a EDT ...

Basenotes has done this to me .......

[Renato]

Your position makes little sense to me. The male designer scent EDTs I own ( with their woody bases) very often last a lot longer and more strongly than the female scent EDPs that my wife owns (with their floral bases).

Male scent EDPs are relatively few in number. Opium EDP is useful if you need a scent that lasts from when you put it on and want it still there when you wake up in the middle of the night. But even then, if you applied Joop Homme EDT or Sables, they would still be there when you woke up in the middle of the next night.

The only times an EDP makes sense to me are in the cases of
a. the more pure, non woody citrus scents, which have pretty poor lasting power in the EDT version, where they EDT is only good for two or three hours, and
b. the generally shorter lasting niche EDT scents, or
c. when the EDP smells significantly different from the EDT version.

Anyhow, that's how I see it. But if you illustrated your position with examples of where you've picked EDPs over EDTs, I might be better able to understand where you are coming from.
Cheers,
Renato

[Surfacing]

if I read the words "extreme" or "concentree" or " double" I am there.

Sure Basteri , but as long as the words "Polo" is not used in combination with "Black", then I am there

[tott]

seriously guys, dont we all want the extra kick?

I certainly do! I started wearing scents during the 80's when perfume was perfume: strongly fragrant, sometimes obnoxious, in your face... but also subtle and sophisticated.

I really dislike anemic reformulations. I get bored by most generically sweet, fresh, aquatic fragrances.

[Aerandir4]

Your position makes little sense to me. The male designer scent EDTs I own ( with their woody bases) very often last a lot longer and more strongly than the female scent EDPs that my wife owns (with their floral bases).

Male scent EDPs are relatively few in number. Opium EDP is useful if you need a scent that lasts from when you put it on and want it still there when you wake up in the middle of the night. But even then, if you applied Joop Homme EDT or Sables, they would still be there when you woke up in the middle of the next night.

The only times an EDP makes sense to me are in the cases of
a. the more pure, non woody citrus scents, which have pretty poor lasting power in the EDT version, where they EDT is only good for two or three hours, and
b. the generally shorter lasting niche EDT scents, or
c. when the EDP smells significantly different from the EDT version.

Anyhow, that's how I see it. But if you illustrated your position with examples of where you've picked EDPs over EDTs, I might be better able to understand where you are coming from.
Cheers,
Renato

I think it depends on your skin type. I have very dry skin and would prefer smoother more potent concentrations of my favourite fragrances. If you make an anology to those fruit drinks that you have to mix with water, some prefer them more dilluted while others prefer a stronger concentration of juice. I for one prefer to spray less fragrance and have better longetivity which again in general is evident with EDP's.

[Renato]

I think it depends on your skin type. I have very dry skin and would prefer smoother more potent concentrations of my favourite fragrances. If you make an anology to those fruit drinks that you have to mix with water, some prefer them more dilluted while others prefer a stronger concentration of juice. I for one prefer to spray less fragrance and have better longetivity which again in general is evident with EDP's.

Some examples would be handy. The few men's EDPs I've tried were not the same scents, but more concentrated - the way typically an EDT is more concentrated than an EDC - but rather were somewhat different scents. They just didn't smell the same to me.
Renato

[Aerandir4]

Some examples would be handy. The few men's EDPs I've tried were not the same scents, but more concentrated - the way typically an EDT is more concentrated than an EDC - but rather were somewhat different scents. They just didn't smell the same to me.
Renato

Perhaps in upping the concentration in EDP's some ingredients are more pronounced then before leaving you with a different smell but I'm sure the differences would be minimal to say the least.

Opium is the obvious example of an improved EDP compared to EDT but there are not enough examples in the mens line for a good comparison, well i don't own any fragrances in EDT & EDP form simultaneously but I have read that some companies formulate EDT's in concentrations similar to EDP's and vice versa so its difficult to tell realistically unless we had more information from the fragrance houses.

Still though if done carefully I would pick an EDP anyday over a EDT.

[jenson]

there is no doubt about the "fact" that Edp's smell a lot more oppulent and richer as compared to edt's. some can live with it, some cant, as in Trebors case. there is nothing strange about it. just the matter of taste. some might be used to parfum extraits too.

[Pollux]

seriously guys, dont we all want the extra kick?

No, a balanced wardrobe is much better, IMHO.

[Nukapai]

I couldn't make a categoric statement like that; in many cases, the EDT/EDP can be slightly different formulas, and the only sensible thing would seem to be to try both and get the one that smells better on you.

About being a perfume snob? I don't think I am, but others might. I have zero cool snob points because I will happily wear something like Love in Paris by Nina Ricci when the mood takes me.

[MFJ]

Sure Basteri , but as long as the words "Polo" is not used in combination with "Black", then I am there

couldnt agree more

I couldn't make a categoric statement like that; in many cases, the EDT/EDP can be slightly different formulas, and the only sensible thing would seem to be to try both and get the one that smells better on you.

About being a perfume snob? I don't think I am, but others might. I have zero cool snob points because I will happily wear something like Love in Paris by Nina Ricci when the mood takes me.

makes alot of sense to me, i may find a scent very generic/overly common, but as long as its pleasing to me, and i find it suitable for an occasion, i wouldnt at all mind wearing it. I dont think i qualify as a snob in any aspect, unless drugstore snob matters at all.
btw Pia, you got a great collection on the pics thread

[Nukapai]

makes alot of sense to me, i may find a scent very generic/overly common, but as long as its pleasing to me, and i find it suitable for an occasion, i wouldnt at all mind wearing it. I dont think i qualify as a snob in any aspect, unless drugstore snob matters at all.
btw Pia, you got a great collection on the pics thread

Yup, that's pretty much my attitude, though I draw the line with certain (not all) celebrity scents. I will not feel comfortable in a scent that would have unpleasant associations. Don't think that's particularly snobbish.

And thank you; I'm 98% happy with the collection. Could do with a couple of tweaks and I'm there.

[nsamadi]

Some EDT's are actually really strong. So, just don't ignore them all.

[irish]

About being a perfume snob? I don't think I am, but others might. I have zero cool snob points because I will happily wear something like Love in Paris by Nina Ricci when the mood takes me.

I could argue that having mainstream scents does not take away any snob points. Even the biggest snobs can appreciate tabu in a snobbily manner.

Nah, but you are cool Nukapai.

[irish]

there is no doubt about the "fact" that Edp's smell a lot more oppulent and richer as compared to edt's.

Lemme rephrese that: there is no doubt about the "fact" that Edp's smell a lot more thick and greasy as compared to edt's.

[jathanas]

I'm not snobbish but I'm dissapointed in most recent designer releases. I've spent so much time sniffing whatever is on display on department store shelves only to be underwhelmed.

I love many older designer releases so I might be fast becoming an "old designer and niche" snob.

[Primrose]

Not me!

I own Caron and Hermes, and I will also wear drugstore cologne...

[DustB]

I can't say exactly where I fall on the edp/edt debate. I actually find edts usually have better sillage or projection, and thus give better kick. And I'm a lover of the extra kick. I find edps sometimes are too close to the skin and seem boring as a result, even though they're clearly richer, denser, and longer lasting.

There was a time I thought about only buying edps though, because it is so wonderful to have a scent on you that's so reliable, so subtle, and yet so dense. Something wonderful to put on because you can put it on and forget about it, never needing to wonder if its still there.

[Amit]

Well, I guess I'm the more traditional snob in here, I'm a Niche snob -- despite all my FB issues. I have trouble accepting designer fragrances into my wardrobe, no matter how good they are. I don't know how that happened, but it has.

As long as I like any particular niche offering, it doesn't matter to me whether it's an EDP or EDT.

[DustB]

I don't think the subject of this thread is snobbery exactly, I think the subject is strong preference for qualities of edps, and how that's a casual application of the concept of being a "snob" for those qualities.

I don't think we need to take the thread on a tangent of who's a snob and if designer or niche fragrances in the wardrobe make a member a snob.

[scentsitivity]

I get good longevity out of lots of EDTs and even some EDCs. Honestly, few scents disappoint me in terms of longevity.

I get more frustration out of anything that 24 hours later needs to get scrubbed off and decides it doesn't want to leave (if you know what I mean).

I am more concerned about whether I enjoy a frag in all its phases than how long it lasts.