I have the EDP. If you'd like to try it again and don't feel like asking your ex for a sample, I can send you one. I remember seeing the EDT at Marshall's and TJMaxx about one year ago for $20-30. It has a lighter color-Hypnose Sheer. I did not try it. Sorry.
A quick search and I found it here for $40:
I am sure there is better price out there.