VPH in half a heartbeat. I love this stuff. It's smells and feels like an aquatic but it isn't. It's really good stuff. It lasts okay too, all day plus on clothes. Ice*Men is a fresh patchouli. Think of A*Men, put it on a diet and starve if further and sprinkle some fresh aqua notes on top.
They are both cool I guess but I'm in love with VPH. Its just so beautiful. I think I'm still the only one with a 200ml bottle