I have only tried Silver Shadow Private and XY out of the 3. Both were kinda average to me. Private was too sweet and XY too minty. If i were to choose out of the 3 i'll go with XY.
Based on what u got...yea u do have a soft spot for aquatics and fresh scents. But can't blame u because of the tropical climate. I love aquatics and fresh scents too. But its a good wardrobe because u have quite a few BN favourites (Rive Gauche, Dreamer and D&G PH).
If u do decide to continue on the aquatic/fresh path, here are some suggestions,
- Davidoff Silver Shadow Altitude
- YSL Live Jazz
- Hermes Concentree D'Orange Verte