Hey man, welcome. If you want the 18-22 year old girls to go wild over you, A&F Fierce will do the trick. A younger scent, but I like the smell. Reminds me of cookies baking.
Check out YSL L'Homme for a more sophisticated scent and D&G The One. Also, Kiehl's Musk for a animalistic vibe (wait for it to dry before you dismiss this one).
Ultimately, all that matters is if you yourself like a fragrance. Try on everything and wait around 15 minutes for the smell to dry down on you before you make your decision. No rush. I'll try on a scent several times before I decide to buy the juice.