I am suspecting that this might be our "Designer" entry. If it is "Drugstore," than this is one of those "inexpensive secrets" that people look for. I don't know that it's a fabulous favorite, but it's interesting and complex with good longevity for a lower-priced scent, if that is what it is.
I think that some of the notes are in common with the first...but there is a definite different feel to this blend of notes. No mint to me, which seemed strong in A. Of course, A didn't end up having mint, so B is probably all mint, just to screw with me.
I do get some faint orange. A fair amount of spice...more cinnamon? The clove is less carnation-y and more like one of those sharp-smelling orange and clove pomader balls. No amber for me. Could the drydown actually be cedar/almond/vanilla? Would someone actually do that?
ETA: Oh, is our "British" clue carrying over?