Thanks! Very interesting. I have to say, for me, they make sense. I love all of Tom Ford's stuff. I haven't sniffed Italian Cypress, but people rave. La Nuit? I think it's damn good, and I bought it, but I REALLY do see it getting second place to something else, so again, good. Haven't tried PS Man.
The bottles? I'll pass. Only barely recall one of three.
The Gucci PH scents are loved here - so much so, that the newer GbGPH is considered weak, even with olfactory references to the earlier scents. Makes sense. TdH? Yes, and with a few dissenters, so second place seems right.
Overall, it just makes sense to me.