I'll be interested in seeing the replies here...
I just picked up some Rive Gauche which certainly seems in that vein.
Pinaud Clubman could be there too.
I think that Old Spice vibe can work for or against you...it can be:
"Oooooooooo, you smell like my dad/uncle/grandfather."
or just as easily
"Ewwwwwww....like you smell like my dad/uncle/grandfather."