I personally think you've made a great choice - it's a wonderful frag and probably Davidoff's best. Actually I ought to get another bottle myself - it's been a couple of years since I used up the last one. It's a nice masculine floral but on the lighter side of masculine florals - more Caron 3rd Man or VC&A Tsar than Czech & Speake 88. I find the BN comments very weird - quite a few that give it a sterling review (one even calls it a masterpiece) but then gives it a middling or thumb down. Anyway, yeah - great choice and good value for money.