Speaking of rose, the rose included in Windsor seems to me much more a relative of the one in Fleurs de The Rose Bulgare than of that in Fleurs de Bulgarie.
One thing I should mention, I am generally disliking rose oils and rose scents. Even those from L'Artisan, a house which I usually like.
I also find rose particularly hard to encapsulate and balance in a man's fragrance.
Hence my admiration for Windsor.