I didn't want to leave such a great post unattended to, though I don't really have much to add! I agree, and I think many others do as well, since the topic of LT and his ratings have been brought up numerous times before. I don't think Allure Homme is a particularly phenomenal fragrance, though I do think it is well deserving of a 3-star rating, and similarly I don't feel Cool Water is good at all, and think that (at least at it's current state, I don't have any experience with it's original formulation) would be generous with a 2-star rating. I feel like LT sometimes puts more credence into technological achievements, and cultural importance rather than plain old smell, which IMO is a mistake. Welcome to BN Karlovonamesti!