Wearing it today for a test and to my nose it's a poor shadow of the EDT, smells like the watered down drydown of the original, sans any lime/mojito (which to me was the only redeeming quality of the original EDT). It just smells too anemic and deathly boring without the spunk of the EDT, honestly, if I had smelled this blind for the first time and was told that it's a Guerlain I woulda loughed out loud (and make a fool of myself...)
The longevity is pretty bad too, after less than two hours it's just a barely perceptible skin scent. The overall impression - they took the EDT, removed the lime/mint, watered down the cr@p out of it and called it a day. It's almost like they were trying to recreate what the EDT should smell like after 8 hours to a person with a chronic sinus infection. Mission accomplished!