Thanks for the long note and introduction. To your question, I would say you would rock the whole town wearing RG PH and Opium PH. Those would be fantastic scents and pretty much unlike anything you've got already. They'd be very nice additions to the collection, and they're both such well made scents that in longevity, creativity, tradition, and interest, they'll not disappoint you. I could be wrong, of course, because it's your nose and not mine, and there's no way I can tell what your nose will like for sure, but I'd wager after a week straight of wearing those two (RG PH is a wonderful scent to wear for a week straight, maybe Opium PH is more fun for Friday night and then Saturday night in a row) you'll think they were your best fragrance buys.
Good luck and keep the town smelling nice!