What do I think? Probably slightly underestimated, yes.
It seems to have a peculiarly even-balanced combination of natural and synthetics which is less natural than the best of Creed, yet less synthetic than the worst of Creed. Hence the effect of people disagreeing on it quite strongly.
I like the semi-light, clean peppery notes... could use longer-lasting citrus... never wanted a bottle of this. The occasional sample satisfied the rare thirst.