Agreed! I do not understand it eigther..
Thread: Habit Rouge
Really trying to understand this one in terms of a masculine scent. I get a powdery old lady scent. Can some one help me understand how this is seen to be masculine. I'm willing to give it time. I want to like it. I want to 'get' it. ;')
Last edited by neal; 26th July 2010 at 02:03 PM.
Agreed! I do not understand it eigther..
It is powdery, but it's a neutral powder. Habit Rouge is actually rather austere compared to Shalimar, for instance. The citrus, spice, incense are always under control and far from voluptous.
It is one of my most hated scents ever ! Powdery old lady fragrance is exactly it ! Even then I would not want to smell it on my Nan !
I believe that perfume is genderless, especially the classic ones. Shalimar was marketed to women but many men around the world love it. It's just the matter of experience. Taste changes often. I'd suggest that you try many other classic scents and get back to Habit Rouge. At first, I hated it, but on my 3rd try I grew to like it.
Current Top 5
1. Creed Aventus
2. A*Men Pure Malt
3. L'instant Extreme
4. Nasomatto Duro
5. CDG - Kyoto
tott is right in using the word "austere." I don't get this scent completely myself. I'm not too much of a leather person and I don't feel like I'd want to add this to my wardrobe. But I can see it as having a place for me in certain type of weather and mood. I imagine it good for an autumn day and a nostalgic mood.
I know there's something there that is appreciated (worshipped?) by so many people. I just need to get it.
I don't know if you can appreciate a fragrance through understanding or intellectualizing aobut it. You either like it and enjoy the way it makes you feel or you don't. Habit Rouge (red coat, riding jacket) is a dressed and civil attitude in a scent that you may not need on you. Some people need to add softness and control to their persona and some don't - it may be you need more danger or adventure in a fragrance? Keith Richards, Sean Connery wear it - supposedly. I don't get powder from HR at all, but it does have softness on the surface and traditional strength that I like. Try the beau cavalier version for more wood in the base, coupled with the soft notes sometimes smells like a fine leather. Its not a party scent or a wake up fresh scent, but it does have its needed place in my wardrobe.
I find it to be a warm and soft scent..... however with maybe a little too much feminine powder note. I believe that most people can stereotype when something is masculine or feminine, yet some people simply overlook it or choose not to categorize. For the average person on the street (not a basenote connoisseur), I would assume that they would call this a women's perfume just because it has too many feminine traits (softness, powdery, etc).
Petty small minded people have no place in my life.
Some of your experience with Habit Rouge depends which version of it you're using-- I find the EDT to be the most powdery and as such, it's my least favorite-- the EDP and EDC are much better on my skin.
The first time I tried Habit Rouge, my experience was similar to the original poster. Over time I learned how to wear Habit Rouge and make it "work". It can be a temperamental scent, and sometimes it can seem to "fight" you a little if you wear it with the wrong clothes or in the wrong situation. Also, I've found that for me it's best to wait a little while after taking my shower to apply Habit Rouge-- otherwise the powder notes tend to amplify.
Give it some time and keep coming back to it to see if you're warming up to it. It's one of the best, but it's not always the easiest to pull off. I don't really find it feminine as much as I do a little bit anachronistic and bold.
Some scents don't work on you from the first try depending on many factors, or might not work on you to begin with. You might one to try Habit Rouge again though since it's a must have in my opinion, but it's definitely a unisex. Try the other editions (EDP is my favorite) as they are less powdery.
As Indie_Guy mentioned, EDC and EDP are not as "powdery" as EDT. Although I like everything Habit Rouge, I would rate vintage EDC as the best (it isn't powdery at all either).
neal - what formulation are you testing? There's EdC, EdT, EdP, Light, Sport and L' Extrait. There are vintage and 'new' formulations.
The proper formulation, makes all of the difference in the world.
I wouldn't be caught dead wearing the 'new' EdT. But I have nothing but love for vintage EdC and the EdP and L'Extrait are deliciously wonderful.
I am sampling the EDT from TPC. I have no way of knowing which reformulation it is unless I email them. I will try the EDC.
The EdT, new or vintage, is by far the most powdery of all incarnations. Powder is the defining aspect of the Guerlain signature, and that powder in Habit Rouge is exactly why some of us fell so deeply for it! At last a masculine daring to be powdery. The powder of Habit Rouge is almost foppish, yet it has the serious and chivalrous masculinity of a patrician in his oiled mahogany rooms redolent with brandy and soft smoke from expensive tobacco. Look out for the patchouli in its base. There's no doubt it's a masculine scent.
I can get what you're saying Neal. It's a classic male scent, but it is indeed from a bit of another time. It's not for everyone. I was lukewarm on the EdT. The EdP (Beau Cavalier in US) is what hooked me and it has become a favorite scent. It has a bit of agarwood in it, which makes it distinct from the EdT or EdC.
It wears nicely on me and I don't feel it's feminine. But as with many scents, a lot of them labeled "unisex," opinions will vary. I don't get a lot of powdery out of it, but the opening notes are a bit odd and intense.
There are some women who love it for themselves. My understanding of HR is that it was developed to be the male counterpart to Shalimar and was one of the first masculine orientals.
I do feel it's a tad more formal. Not tuxedo level, but I don't as yet wear it when casually dressed. Usually suit or sport coat.
I also feel it leans more mature and serious. But I don't want any young guys who love it to come kick my butt.
I have a guess Neal, you've sampled it the same reason I did. You see it chatted up in glowing terms as a classic and wanted to see what all the noise was about. But some people just don't like it. I would advocate that the Beau Cavalier version may be more to your liking.
Last edited by StylinLA; 26th July 2010 at 06:29 PM.
Don't think too much or try too hard. Sometimes, all it comes down to is that you simply don't like it. There is nothing wrong with that. There are plenty of "classic" scents that are unwearable to me. It's not a calculus exam. it's a fragrance, and it should be fun...
In a sort of way, I think there is no sense! If you have to struggle, over, and over, and over again, with several wearings, to find "something" that make you like the scent... -spend your money on something else that you realy like!
Love this stuff could drink if out of the bottle if possible
I do not find it powerdry at all very bracing and masculine with citrus and leather and just a touch of vanilla.
However, re Habit Rouge, you could try the EDT Legere. IMO it is has brighter citrus top-notes and "powdery" will not be your first impression of its dry-down, yet it retains the essence of HR. I love this version a lot.
ointments and perfume delight the heart....
Agreed on the EdT complaints. It was the first version I tried, and I almost avoided the scent permanently after that. I found it to be completely unbalanced and a little sickening - the citrus doesn't know when the quit, and it clashes horribly with the powder.
So, if you are speaking of the EdT, I don't blame you for not liking it.
Luckily, I tried the EdC not long after. The citrus is brighter and burns off to reveal a beautiful base that feels more like animalic incense than direct powder. I love it. Need to try the EdP soon.
"It's not what you look like when you're doing what you're doing; it's what you're doing when you're doing what you look like you're doing."
I tried Habit Rouge EDT and didn't enjoy it as much as I thought I would, especially when the patchouli rears up. But that was more than a year ago and a lot has happened to my nose since, lol. I gotta try this one again...
Habit Rouge EDT is an old style oriental - by which I mean akin to Lagerfeld Classic, Royal Copenhagen, KL Homme. They're often powdery, but they're not really party scents like most modern day orientals. Most can be worn to work without any problem.
Talcum powder used to be part of male gift sets, but I don't know of any males who use it anymore. Perhaps your "old lady" association comes from the powdery part of the scent, as women still seem to use it at times.
Last edited by Renato; 26th July 2010 at 08:22 PM.
Probably the best thing I’ve smelled or worn. I dislike powder, but find Habit Rouge’s lofty dust comparable to the vigor of toweling off after a shower. But in general, it’s HR’s velvety, earthy, almost root-like suave accord that gets my attention far more than the dust.
I smelled it first in my early twenties, but it took awhile before I wanted to wear it. After that it was always a favorite. Still is. Try the edc. The edp is alright but a little dense. Sort of a darker, muddled, more lactonic HR, but a good fragrance nevertheless.
Last edited by pluran; 1st August 2010 at 02:19 AM.
Have worn HR on and off for about 40 or more years. Bought other scents in between because got tired of it. Bought even LOTS of other scents - and always "rediscovered" HR as the very, very best of quality scents. Thank heavens tastes differ and not EVERYbody likes it because then the world would smell of HR only. Liking a perfume is such a personal thing that there shouldn't be any TRYING to like one. Either you do or you don't, period. Don't create a problem where there is none. Be happy with what you like and be happy with what you dislike. The world would be a lot more boring if we all had the same taste.