I own and love Shalimar, but I voted Kenzo Flower for a young girl. It's hard to know which fragrance someone else will prefer, though, unless you know the person well. For a young girl, I think Shalimar Light or Eau de Shalimar might be nice. Just because Kenzo Flower is more recent doesn't mean she will like it, so it's difficult to say. It would depend on what I knew of the girl's taste.