Thread: "Erolfa" by Creed?
But they also told me Napoleon couldn't live without Bois du Portugal... And I BELIEVED them!!!! They just wait, the next time I see that SA, he'll get a thrashing from me for telling me all those dirty lies...
ps: does anybody know about the specifics of Caesarean Basil compared to the generic variant? Same with Morrocan Tangerine. But Sandalwood - which kind is it - Australian or Indian? Musk?
Erolfa certainly smells herbal to my nose and its one of the most complex aquatics on the market - theres a lot of citrus in the top notes, and I get a lot of herbs in the middle notes phase.
I am assuming you must have read over a 1000 fragrance pyramids in your lifetime...if you know the industry well, do you believe that every ingredient they list is an actual singular ingredient? It can be an amalgamate, or just an impression, or an actual ingredient.
You need to try Erolfa on your skin, and spend some time analyzing it. A 30 second test on a strip at a perfume shop (alongwith testing 30 other fragrances) is not a fair trial.
It does indeed smell very differently on one's skin.
I saw some reviewer posts and comments saying that Erolfa could easily be compared to other popular "youth" fragrances. Uh, really? :O
I personally loathe this fragrance. But if you like it, that is all that matters.
Please feel free to check out my Swap Thread - Patou pour Homme, L'Instant de Guerlain PH Extreme, Dior Homme Intense, Pure Malt, Pure Coffee and many more! Click Here For My Swap Thread
I don't get the connection to Odeur #53, sorry. O/k, there is something. O53 may consist of 53 ingredients, but it doesn't smell of any of them specifically. The notes list of O53 is not a fraud in that it makes You believe in precious naturals. It travels the line between free association and nasty. Open handed. I took the offer that O53 provides. Alas, it's hard to talk about - no pyramid ...
I find Erolfa to be an excellent tangy, abstract orange (equal doses orange and ozone) with salt and a smattering of herbs over a dry driftwood accord.
It's excellent, but lately I've begun to favor L'Artisan's Navegar which also presents a citrus/sea air/wood scent, but takes all elements in different directions. I find Navegar to be a bit rougher, whereas Erolfa is tart but smooth, and Navegar is definitely spicier. It replaces the orange of Erolfa with lime, the herbs with pepper and cedar (and a hint of anise and rum to darken things up), and a wonderful frankincense note in the drydown that augments the ozone accord. I find that it has a bit more character than Erolfa and evokes a different image in my mind: where Erolfa is a driftwood littered beach at high noon, Navegar is the sea
spray and wind on an ancient merchant ship carrying spices from the orient. I also find Navegar to be wearable in more situations, whereas Erolfa is relegated to bright sunny days or those days actually spent at or on the water.
Iris Pallida 50ml
Ungaro I 75ml
and more! - http://www.basenotes.net/threads/301...n-Man-and-more
I used to have a 1oz bottle of Erolfa & I sold it, later. However I miss it.
Erolfa is quite unique. I can't think of any fragrance out there that replicates the salty accord of Erolfa, although TDC Sel De Vetiver does deserve an honorable mention here. My only complaint against Erolfa was it's appalling longevity. Since I just had a tiny 1 oz bottle I could see it disappearing fast as I used to overspray, to make it last. That's the reason I just sold it.
Now my perception has changed and I don't get as perturbed about longevity as I used to. This brings Erolfa back into my game and I would certainly buy a bottle as soon as I can.
I'm worried because I seem to be the only one who doesn't smell any salt
Creed Erolfa: aromachemical calone => specific smell brown algae => seaside => salty taste of air
Heely Sel Marine: celery is as adstringent to the tounge as salt is (same with Sel De Vetiver?!)
If You have not yet made this association in real life, the effect will expectedly fail.
I live near the beach but uh, no, no salt for me.
Guys....does anyone know when did Creed discontinue the 'ship design' boxes of Erolfa?
I am pretty sure the current box does not exhibit the sailing ship anymore.
I quizzed the Creed rep on what "Erolfa" stood for. Well, she had no idea. I felt like a know it all schoolin' her. She looked annoyed
Erolfa and Original Santal are two Creed fragrances that I really like and have still not managed to get hold of a bottle. I do have 10ml decants of each. The Creed UK site has shown the new bottle design for quite a while now, so I'm not certain when this was changed. There are also many online shops showing the new bottle design, which they have simply copied from Creed's website, but when you quiz them about the bottle you would actualy receive, they are still selling the older one. This false advertising really cheeses me off, as there is no way I would pay good money for old stock, so make certain you know what bottle you will receive before parting with your cash, as these are not the only bottles Creed have changed the design on.
I own a (old) bottle of Erolfa with the old design. I like the top and middle, but after some hours on my skin it turns out to smell quite sour and "sharp". Maby It`s to old and gone bad? I have read that the "new" Erolfa is much fresher, without the sour dry-down. Is that right?
- Eny opinions?
The newer bottle is very fresh, maybe less "sharp", and also less distinctive. It's still very good, but not great, and it never has been a "great" scent, IMHO. It's a fresh, different type of smell that is simply a change-up in my collection, certainly not one of my mainstays. Definitely just a nice extra in my collection, but it has risen above Himalaya and Original Vetiver in my eyes.
My current full-bottle Creeds, in order of my preference:
3. Original Santal
5. Acier Aluminum
6. Millesime Imperial
It's a typical Creed offering. Smells glorious for a while then vanishes.
From bottle to bottle? Isn't that just Creed?
"Aw crap! Just stick some stuff in a VAT which smells a bit like the last lot we did, pretend it was worn by some obscure royalty in a European state nobody's heard of and then, when nobody's noticed, raise the bottle price by $20. Then, in six months time, we'll produce a slightly (but only slightly, sh*t some of those chemicals are expensive!) stronger version, call it "Vintage" because we'll make up an olde worlde date for it and charge $150 more for a half size bottle of that version."
In a world where people smell bad, it is the personal responsibility of every Basenoter to improve the world one SotD at a time...
All in all, Erolfa, Bvlgari Aqva and Kenzo pour homme are the best marine scents I've ever smelt.
Erolfa's opening exhibits a sharp herbal citrus - bright, brilliant and colorful. I recall the green aspect of it, as well as the aquatic/marine accords achieved by the use of ambergris. I've not tried recent batches but I actually do find many ladies enjoy wearing Erolfa.
I felt EROLFA was a bit too one-note. Lots of salt, lots of sand and ozonic stuff, all well-rendered, but nothing very compelling, and honestly, for the money, I'd skip it.
I much prefer the new version, even though it lacks the great longevity of the old version..
Someone know when Erolfa shower-gel was discontinued? You can still get it from strawberrynet.com.
Own it, love it. Very good for beach and resort wear. Good in warm weather, or whenever you want to remind yourself of a pleasant day at the beach. Bleu de Chanel reminds me of Erolfa, in that both seem kind of simple and fresh at first, but subtleties emerge with repeated wearings. Both are good from beginning to end, which is something I rarely think about fragrances in the fresh category. Lesser fresh fragrances often develop obnoxious synthetic-smelling notes, akin to insecticide, about halfway through. Erolfa and Bleu de Chanel skate right by that phase, and stay beautiful to the end. I get good longevity from both.
Erolfa is great. To me, it's a mashup of MI, VIW, and maybe some Royal Water. It's a summer frag though, will dissappear off your skin in the winter.